The Final Decision: Why Your High School Senior May Be Stuck

It’s all good.  Your high school student applied to multiple colleges — and they’ve been accepted to all of them.  You’ve made it through the harrowing admissions process.

But wait, the process isn’t quite over yet.  You and your student have survived the agonizing wait, but now the ball is back in your student’s court.  They need to make a decision — in just a few short weeks they will need to decide which college to attend.  This sounds like an ideal dilemma, but put the emphasis on dilemma.

For some soon-to-be college students the decision is easy.  They have had a clear favorite from the beginning and there is no hesitation.  For many more students, however, the decision may not be as clear.  There are many factors to weigh, options to consider.  For many high school students, this is not only a big decision; this may be the first major life decision that they have had to make.  To many students, this decision may be overwhelming and paralyzing.

Many students struggle with the college decision not only because it is a big decision, and because students feel there is only one right decision, but because making this decision requires a lot of soul searching and self-understanding.  These are not necessarily easy things for teenagers to accomplish. ”Know thyself” may be good advice, but it is not easy.  However, the more that your student can honestly explore the question of what matters to them, the more clear the college decision may become.

High school students faced with this decision are often given good advice about factors to consider.  Perhaps you’ve even suggested some of these to your student.

  • Consider the bottom line financial cost
  • Consider the environment — big school/small school, city/suburban/rural, Greek life, etc.
  • Consider your extracurricular interests/opportunities — athletics, music, drama, community action
  • Consider academics — majors, internship opportunities, graduation rates
  • Consider the college’s reputation, distance from home, diversity, facilities

All of these factors, and many more, are important, and considering them may help your student narrow down their choices.

However, it is essential that your student take another step to hold the mirror up and think closely about who they are and what matters to them.  This may be easier for some students and more difficult for others.  It may be downright uncomfortable for some. Here are some questions that you might suggest that your student consider.  Don’t expect them to answer these questions for you, they are things your student needs to answer honestly on their own.

  • Create your must-have list.  What are make-or-break factors in a college?  Now — take time to think about why the things on your list are there.  Why are they ”must haves?”  What really matters?  What does your list say about you?
  • Close your eyes and visualize your ideal college experience.  What are you doing?  Who is there?  How does it feel?  Take time to see the details in your mind’s eye.  Now think about each college.  Which comes closest to your ideal vision?  Why?
  • How do you define success?  Don’t just think about the obvious, superficial successes you may encounter day-to-day, think about true success in life.  Does it have to do with career, money, accomplishments, changing the world, relationships with other people, religious or moral factors?  Now think about each college in terms of your goals.  How does each school align with what you want?
  • Think about your high school experiences — the very good and the not-so-good.  Why were they good or bad?  How much do you want to duplicate your high school experience and how much are you looking for something different?  Which school offers what you need?
  • What matters most to you in life?  What are your priorities?  How would you rank connection to family, adventure, exploring diversity, challenge, social connections, career development, or other factors?  Why are those things important to you?  Which school will help you with what matters?
  • How ready do you feel for college?  What areas are you most confident about and what areas worry you?  Will any of your college choices better help you achieve in those areas in which you feel strong and support you in your weaker areas?  How do you know that?

These are not easy questions to answer, and your student may struggle with several of them.  But whether your student’s approach to the college decision is methodical and organized or more organic, these questions may help them find the important synthesis between who they are and the college that may be a better match.

Whatever your student decides, it is important that they keep in mind that ultimately, the college experience will be what they make of it.  Once your student decides on a school, their next important decision will be to decide to be happy, to take advantage of all of the possibilities.

And as a college parent, you may need to bite your tongue.  You will need to remember that the choice of college is a very personal one.  You may never completely understand why your student makes the choice that they do, but you will provide the support and the sounding board as they live out their college experience.  It is an adventure for both of you.

Related Posts:

College Parents: Hold That Advice!

Why Your High School Senior Is So Stressed Right Now

Why Your Student Should Attend Accepted or Admitted Student Day

Saying “No Thank You” to a College Acceptance

Accepted to College – Now What?


FirstTerm banner ad

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Log In


Log In to Favorite articles and Post listings

Enter College Name to See Local Results

Log In

Contact Us

Forgot your password?

Your new password has been sent to your email!

Logout Successful!

Find Your School

You just missed it! This listing has been filled.

Post your own housing listing on Uloop and have students reach out to you!

Upload An Image

Please select an image to upload
Note: must be in .png, .gif or .jpg format
Provide URL where image can be downloaded
Note: must be in .png, .gif or .jpg format
Please enter First Name Please enter Last Name Please enter Phone
Please enter Email
Please enter Message

By clicking this button,
you agree to the terms of use

Please enter Email

By clicking "Create Alert" I agree to the Uloop Terms of Use.

Image not available.

Success, your registration has been submitted

An email has been sent to you with a link to verify your registration
Image not available.
By clicking Get Started or Sign In you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service