The College Decision Dilemma

The letters have arrived.  Some of the news may not be what was hoped for.  Hopefully, most of the news was good.  Your student has been accepted — perhaps to multiple schools.  As stressful as the wait may have been, those letters arrive with a new kind of stress. Your student now has options.  The decision is now in your student’s hands.  The ball is back in their court.  They must now decide which offer to accept.

Recent research on both the relationship between students and their parents and on communication between students and their parents tells us that that in the vast majority of families, parents will help students make this important decision.  Your student wants to hear your opinion and values your input.  However, it is important to remember that as overwhelming as it may seem, this must be your student’s decision.  They will need to feel good about this decision, live with this decision, and make the college experience work.  It is your job to be a helpful passenger on this journey, but not a back-seat driver.

So what can you do to help your student as they face this decision dilemma?  This may be an ideal time to begin to practice some of the good communication skills that you and your student will need throughout the college years.  Here are a few suggestions:

  • Perhaps there really is no dilemma for your student.  They have known all along which school they want to attend, they were accepted, and they are certain about their decision.  Congratulate them, affirm their decision, be thankful, and move on.  (Lucky you!)
  • Even if your student is struggling with a decision, don’t forget to help them focus on the congratulations that they were accepted to several schools and now face this decision.  The acceptance is a big step.  Help them savor the moment.
  • Remind your student that there is no ”perfect” college.  They may feel that there is only one correct decision  to make and anything else will mean disaster.  Your student wants to make the decision that feels best to them, but there may be more than one good choice.
  • Talk to your student about financial considerations if they need to be a factor in this decision.  Look together carefully at any financial aid offers.  Follow up with the school’s financial aid office if necessary.  Let your student know clearly whether there is a bottom line that will eliminate any school as an option.
  • Help your student think about what factors they might weigh as they decide.  Do they want to think about size? Location? Type of school — urban, suburban? Majors offered and ease of changing majors if they change their mind? Sports options? Extracurricular activities? Fraternities or sororities?  Some factors may matter and others may not.  Help your student determine which are important.
  • Help your student consider whether they need any additional information at this point.  Can they attend an Accepted Student event or spend an overnight at the college?  Should they talk to someone in their major department?
  • Be willing and available to discuss your student’s decision with them, but be willing to leave them alone to wrestle with it.  Don’t ask every day whether they have decided.  Although they may not be overtly talking about what they are thinking, your student is almost certainly working on it internally.
  • Be willing to be a sounding board, but don’t feel the need to provide answers.  Patience and empathy may be the most important gifts that you can give your student right now.  Let them know that you recognize that this may be a difficult decision and that they are feeling stressed.  Let them know that you trust that they are capable of making a good decision.
  • Be patient.  Your student may not make a final decision until the last minute.  They may actually know what they want to do earlier, but the final commitment seems so — final.  Your student may hold off until the last moment.
  • Trust your student’s ”gut reaction.”  If your student has a favorite school but can’t seem to pin down why other than it simply feels right, trust that.  Sometimes, the right match may defy logic — but your student knows that they feel at home on a campus.

So much time, energy, and investment has gone in to the college admission process that this final moment of decision may seem overwhelming to your student. They have been building toward this moment for several years.  Although it truly marks just the beginning of the college journey, it often feels like a final moment — the moment when your student becomes a college student.  Making this decision is an act of both the head and the heart, an art and not a science.  It takes, in some ways a great leap of faith and a tremendous amount of courage.

As your high school student makes the college decision, they become a college student — and you become a college parent. Congratulations to you both!   Celebrate with your student, explore options with your student, support your student’s decision.  Enjoy the new adventure!

Related Posts:

Why Your Student Should Attend Accepted or Admitted Student Day

Is Your Student Heading to College for the Right Reasons?

Can a College Revoke My Student’s Admission?

Should My College Student Consider Deferring Enrollment for College?

Your Five Most Important Jobs as a College Parent

FirstTerm banner ad

3 thoughts on “The College Decision Dilemma”

  1. As a private college counselor, I know you have made some great suggestions to help students make their final college decision. I think discussing the pros and cons of each school and guiding students to their own decision is usually very effective. Many students also have a gut reaction and it is worth talking about that.

  2. Thanks for your comment Monica. Glad you are finding the site helpful. If you already have a college student, you know how complex college parenting can be! We need all of the help we can get!


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Log In


Log In to Favorite articles and Post listings

Enter College Name to See Local Results

Log In

Contact Us

Forgot your password?

Your new password has been sent to your email!

Logout Successful!

Find Your School

You just missed it! This listing has been filled.

Post your own housing listing on Uloop and have students reach out to you!

Upload An Image

Please select an image to upload
Note: must be in .png, .gif or .jpg format
Provide URL where image can be downloaded
Note: must be in .png, .gif or .jpg format
Please enter First Name Please enter Last Name Please enter Phone
Please enter Email
Please enter Message

By clicking this button,
you agree to the terms of use

Please enter Email

By clicking "Create Alert" I agree to the Uloop Terms of Use.

Image not available.

Success, your registration has been submitted

An email has been sent to you with a link to verify your registration
Image not available.
By clicking Get Started or Sign In you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service